Vins Américains

Je viens de recevoir cette liste des States. Y a-t-il des must buy ??? Mes connaissances de vins Américains est très limitées et on ne cesse de me dire qu'il n'y a pas que Bordeaux dans la vie.

RP WS Sale Per
Quantity Format Year Wine Rating Rating Bottle
1 750 1999 2480 Hollywood & Vine 91 89 50
10 750 2001 2480 Hollywood & Vine 92 58
1 3000 2002 2480 Hollywood & Vine 91 221
4 750 1997 Cakebread Cabernet 85 68
10 750 1999 Cakebread Cabernet 91 73
9 750 2001 Cakebread Cabernet 88 88 92
1 750 2002 Cakebread Cabernet 89 46
11 750 2005 Cakebread Cabernet 86 88 49
3 750 1999 Cakebread Cabernet Benchland 87 89 84
1 750 2004 Casa Dalla Valle 33
4 750 1999 Caymus Special Selection 90 95 126
6 750 2001 Caymus Special Selection 93+ 95 112
3 750 2005 Caymus Special Selection 92-94 94 112
5 750 1999 Chateau Montelena 95 94 89
1 1500 1999 Chateau Montelena 95 94 178
1 1500 2001 Chateau Montelena 95 126
1 1500 2001 Chateau Montelena 95 126
2 1500 2001 Chateau Montelena 95 126
10 750 2002 Chateau Montelena 95+ 80
2 750 1997 Chateau St Jean Cinq Cepages 94 68
2 750 1997 Clos Pegase Hommage 41
2 1500 2002 Conn Valley Cabernet 94 81
5 750 2005 Conn Valley Right Bank 94 34
5 750 1997 Cornerstone Cabernet 94 50
2 750 1999 Dalla Valle Cabernet 94 89
1 750 1999 Dalla Valle Cabernet 94 89
3 750 2000 David Arthur 1147 Elevation 92 88
1 750 2001 David Arthur 1147 Elevation 96 224
2 1500 2002 David Arthur 1147 Elevation 87 165
1 1500 2005 David Arthur 1147 Elevation 75 150
2 750 2002 David Arthur Cabernet 87 41
1 750 2003 David Arthur Cabernet 85 54
2 750 2001 David Arthur Meritaggio 87 27
1 750 2003 David Arthur Meritaggio 45
1 750 1996 Delectus Cuvee Julia 69
3 750 1999 Delectus Cuvee Julia 87 69
1 1500 2002 Delectus Dog Gone Good 87 62
1 1500 2003 Delectus Dog in Style 86 35
2 750 1997 Diamond Creek Gravelly Meadow 93 108
2 750 1998 Diamond Creek Red Rock Terrace 94 81
2 750 1998 Diamond Creek Volcanic Hill 94 77
1 750 2001 Dominus 88 89
2 1500 2002 Dominus 92 189
3 750 2002 Dominus 92 95
8 750 2002 Dominus Napanook 92 35
5 750 2002 Duckhorn 25th Anniversary 36
6 750 1997 Duckhorn Cabernet 86 90 36
3 750 1999 Duckhorn Cabernet 86 36
1 3000 2001 Duckhorn Cabernet 88 94 215
1 3000 2001 Duckhorn Cabernet 88 94 215
1 3000 2002 Duckhorn Cabernet 85 87 140
1 3000 2002 Duckhorn Cabernet 25th Anniversary 143
1 3000 2002 Duckhorn Merlot 90 89 215
1 3000 2001 Duckhorn Merlot Estate Grown 89 91 229
1 3000 2002 Duckhorn Merlot Estate Grown 86 90 229
5 750 1997 Dunn Howell Mountain 95 113
1 1500 1997 Dunn Howell Mountain 95 225
1 1500 1999 Etude Cabernet 93 162
1 1500 2001 Etude Cabernet 90 114
9 750 1999 Far Niente Cabernet 70
12 750 2001 Far Niente Cabernet 88 78
1 1500 2005 Faust (Quintessa 2nd label) 66
1 1500 2005 Foley Claret 92 149
1 750 1997 Frogs Leap 50
8 750 2005 Futo Family OV 95+ 98
3 750 1997 Girard Cabernet 89 58
5 750 2005 Grace Family 88 186
1 750 1994 Groth Reserve 89 70
4 750 2005 Harlan Estate 97 387
1 750 2001 Harrison Reserve Cabernet 37
8 750 1999 Jones Family Cabernet 91 59
1 1500 1999 Jones Family Cabernet 91 118
2 1500 2001 Jones Family Cabernet 95 178
1 1500 1999 Joseph Phelps Backus 90 98
1 1500 2004 Justin Cabernet 37
1 750 1999 Justin Isosceles 91 71
1 750 1991 La Jota 10th Anniversary 94 90 89
1 750 1992 La Jota 11th Anniversary 98 89 80
1 750 1993 La Jota 12th Anniversary 96 91 71
1 750 1994 La Jota 13th Anniversary 96 93 89
1 750 1995 La Jota 14th Anniversary 94 89 68
1 750 1996 La Jota 15th Anniversary 96 93 63
3 750 1997 La Jota 16th Anniversary 93 91 71
3 750 2001 Laird Cabernet 25
3 750 2005 Lewis Cabernet 66
2 1500 1999 Lewis Reserve Cabernet 93 108
15 750 2005 Lewis Reserve Cabernet 93 69
1 750 1999 Lokoya Howell 87 78
1 1500 2001 Lokoya Mt Veeder 97 270
11 750 1999 Matanzas Creek Journey 84 83
1 750 1997 Matanzas Creek Merlot 86 41
2 750 2005 Maybach Materium 96 161
6 750 2005 Merus Cabernet 96+ 126
3 750 1997 Mitisse Cabernet 92
3 750 2002 Neal Family 40
4 750 1999 Pahlmeyer Meritage 90 74
5 750 2001 Phelps Backus 93 114
5 750 2001 Phelps Cabernet 88 41
2 750 2002 Phelps Cabernet 90 41
12 750 2005 Phelps Cabernet 89 29
8 750 1999 Phelps Insignia 91 81
6 750 2001 Phelps Insignia 95 90
1 750 1997 Philip Togni Cabernet 98 107
1 3000 2002 Pine Ridge Cabernet 88 153
1 750 1997 Plumpjack Cabernet 90 82
3 750 1999 Plumpjack Cabernet 87 79
2 750 2001 Plumpjack Cabernet 90-92 96
11 750 2002 Plumpjack Cabernet 92 54
14 750 2003 Plumpjack Cabernet 92-94 75
19 750 2005 Plumpjack Cabernet 92 68
5 750 2005 Plumpjack Cabernet 92 68
5 750 2001 Plumpjack Cabernet Reserve 94-96 158
1 750 2003 Plumpjack Cabernet Reserve 95 158
9 750 1999 Pride Cabernet 88 92 50
7 750 2002 Pride Cabernet 92 93 66
2 750 2005 Pride Cabernet 92 87 53
10 750 2005 Pride Cabernet 92 87 53
25 750 2005 Pride Reserve 93+ 96 98
10 750 2005 Pride Reserve Cabernet 93+ 96 98
1 750 1996 Quintessa 91 73
26 750 1999 Quintessa 89 91 77
2 750 1999 Quintessa 89 91 77
2 1500 2001 Quintessa 88 86 65
12 750 2005 Quintessa 88 73
7 750 1997 Ridge Montebello Meritage 90-91 108
16 750 1999 Ridge Montebello Meritage 77
6 750 2001 Ridge Montebello Meritage 95+ 106
5 1500 2002 Ridge Montebello Meritage 94 180
4 750 2002 Ridge Montebello Meritage 94 90
7 750 1997 Ristow Cabernet 42
7 750 1999 Robert Craig Affinity 89 38
22 750 2005 Robert Foley Claret 92 80
4 750 1997 Seavey 96 99
1 750 2001 Shafer Cabernet 90 45
1 1500 2001 Shafer Merlot 90 66
1 1500 2003 Sherwin Family 123
17 750 2002 Silver Oak Napa 91 74
2 750 2003 Silver Oak Napa 89 58
2 750 2001 Simi Reserve 32
1 750 1997 Spottswoode Cabernet 93 94 70
1 750 1999 Spottswoode Cabernet 90 55
1 1500 1999 Spottswoode Cabernet 90 109
2 750 2001 Spottswoode Cabernet 95 90
1 1500 2001 Spottswoode Cabernet 95 180
4 750 1997 Spring Mountain Reserve 88 54
1 750 1999 Spring Mountain Reserve 58
1 750 1999 Staglin Family 89 45
3 750 1997 Sterling Reserve 61
6 750 2005 Switchback Ridge Cabernet 95 88
1 1500 2005 Switchback Ridge Cabernet 95 176
5 750 2002 Viader 50
1 750 2002 Viader 50
2 750 2001 Waterstone Cabernet 9
5 750 2002 Waterstone Cabernet 89 12
6 750 2003 Waterstone Cabernet 15
14 750 2001 Whitehall Lane Cabernet 91 32
9 750 2001 Whitehall Lane Cabernet 91 32
5 750 2002 Whitehall Lane Cabernet 87 26
1 750 2002 Whitehall Lane Cabernet 87 26
3 750 1997 Whitehall Lane Cabernet Reserve 87 91 77
1 1500 1997 Whitehall Lane Cabernet Reserve 87 88 143
1 750 1999 Whitehall Lane Cabernet Reserve 93 54
3 750 2001 Whitehall Lane Cabernet Reserve 93 55
3 750 2001 Whitehall Lane Cabernet Reserve 91 55
6 750 2001 D'Arenberg the Dead Arm 98 77
1 1500 2001 D'Arenberg the Dead Arm 98 153
3 750 2001 Kay Brothers Shiraz Block Six 96-98 72
2 750 2001 Old Bastard Shiraz 96 90
2 750 2001 Shirvington Shiraz 98 72
1 750 1985 Dows Vintage Port 87 50
1 750 1985 Fonseca Port 90 60
4 750 2000 Fonseca Port 95 94 59
3 750 1985 Quinta do Noval Vintage Port 87 41
1 750 2000 Taylor Fladgate Port 98 68
1 750 1997 Warres Vintage Port 32
1 750 2000 Warres Vintage Port 91 41

Le dernier chiffre étant le prix

J'irais avec Elevation 1147 de David Arthur, Togni ou Dunn.

RP WS Sale Per
Quantity Format Year Wine Rating Rating Bottle
4 750 1999 Caymus Special Selection 90 95 126
6 750 2001 Caymus Special Selection 93+ 95 112
3 750 2005 Caymus Special Selection 92-94 94 112
5 750 1999 Chateau Montelena 95 94 89
1 1500 1999 Chateau Montelena 95 94 178
1 1500 2001 Chateau Montelena 95 126
1 1500 2001 Chateau Montelena 95 126
2 1500 2001 Chateau Montelena 95 126
10 750 2002 Chateau Montelena 95+ 80
2 750 1999 Dalla Valle Cabernet 94 89
1 750 1999 Dalla Valle Cabernet 94 89
3 750 2000 David Arthur 1147 Elevation 92 88
1 750 2001 David Arthur 1147 Elevation 96 224
2 1500 2002 David Arthur 1147 Elevation 87 165
1 1500 2005 David Arthur 1147 Elevation 75 150
1 1500 2005 Foley Claret 92 149
4 750 2005 Harlan Estate 97 387
6 750 2005 Merus Cabernet 96+ 126
1 750 1997 Philip Togni Cabernet 98 107
1 750 1997 Spottswoode Cabernet 93 94 70
1 750 1999 Spottswoode Cabernet 90 55
1 1500 1999 Spottswoode Cabernet 90 109
2 750 2001 Spottswoode Cabernet 95 90
1 1500 2001 Spottswoode Cabernet 95 180



pis si tu ne veux pas le harlan mais peut me le rapporter, je le prendrais bien moi...

1997 Seavey 96 99
1997 Philip Togni Cabernet 98 107 (Très grande bouteille sur ce millésime)
1999 Dalla Valle Cabernet 94 89
2005 Harlan Estate 97 387
1999 Chateau Montelena 95 94 89
2001 Chateau Montelena 95

Pas d'hésitation, c'est aussi bon qu'à bordeaux !